Trying to figure out which coffee to get at Costco? Overwhelmed with choices or just want to try something new?
Then buckle up because we are about to embark on an in-depth journey to uncover the best coffee available at Costco.
Now, you might be wondering, “With so many choices, where do I even begin?” Don’t worry, we’ve got you covered!
We’re sharing our picks for the top 5 coffees you can grab on your next run.
What's the best coffee at Costco?
Peet’s Major Dickenson is the best coffee at Costco. This is because it has rich, smooth, yet intricate flavor profile that is low in acidity.
At first glance, you might come across a few hits and misses – after all, not every coffee can be a perfect match for you. From light and smooth breakfast blends to deep, intense roasts that will wake you up in an instant, Costco offers an impressive selection of coffee beans and grounds to satisfy any palate.
Our mission is to simplify your coffee quest, providing you with clear and concise recommendations that are great for you – because coffee should be enjoyed, not puzzled over!
Criteria for Selection: Sift Through the Coffee Wonderland
When strolling down the coffee aisle at Costco, I’m like a kid in a candy store with so many options to choose from! But I don’t just grab any ol’ bag of beans. Here are the factors I consider when selecting the best brews:
Flavor profile and taste
This is arguably the most important criteria. I want a coffee that smells amazing and has multidimensional flavors that come through from the first sip to the last drop. Whether it’s nutty, chocolaty, fruity, or floral, the taste needs to make my taste buds do a happy dance.
Roast level
How dark or light the beans are roasted directly impacts the flavor. I evaluate light, medium, and dark options to find the intensity and boldness my palate desires that day.
Whole bean vs. ground
Whole beans retain freshness longer, while pre-ground coffee makes for an easier, faster brew. I choose based on my brewing method and time constraints.
Keep in mind we’re buying in bulk. Buying 2 lbs of ground coffee is tough to consume before the freshness date with only 2 coffee drinkers in the house. The quality slowly diminishes and by the time you’re at the bottom you’re brewing sawdust and you don’t even know it.
Organic and sustainable
I aim for coffees that are good for the Earth and farmers. Organic, Fair Trade, shade-grown are all pluses in my book.
Top 5 Coffee at Costco
5. Mayorga Café Cubano Roast
Picture this – a rich, dark roast that’s velvety smooth, with no hint of that pesky burnt aftertaste! Meet Mayorga Café Cubano Roast, a coffee gem that’s sure to make its way into your heart and your mug.
One thing that sets this dark roast apart is its low acidity level, making it a perfect pick for those who crave a bold coffee experience without any sharp tang. And here’s an intriguing feature: the beans have a delightful oiliness, so if you’re planning to use a super-automatic espresso machine, this is definitely something to consider!
Who’s this dark delight ideal for, you may wonder? If you revel in the allure of bold, dark roasts and have a soft spot for Fair Trade coffee, then look no further – this one’s for you! Espresso aficionados seeking a touch of toastiness and a heavenly chocolatey taste will find their coffee soulmate in a dark roast.
And let’s not forget the icing on the coffee cake – it’s OU Kosher certified, and USDA Certified Organic! Mayorga Café Cubano Roast goes above and beyond to ensure a quality coffee experience you can savor guilt-free.
Read the full review here.
4. San Francisco Bay Organic Rainforest Blend
If you’re looking for an intense, bold coffee that doesn’t sacrifice complex flavor, this organic blend should be on your radar. One sip of these dark roasted beans will transport your taste buds to the misty, rugged rainforests this coffee is named after.
This particular brew is what we’d categorize as a very dark roast – think of those “French” roasts you may have heard about. The nearly blackened beans give it an assertive, smokey character that’s not for the faint of heart. But don’t let the dark color fool you – there are still lovely nuanced notes to discover in each cup. Sniff out tones of chocolate, nuts, and spice swirling through the blend.
If you’re eco-conscious, you’d be pleased to know this leans into organic agriculture and sustainable farming practices. And without breaking your wallet, it offers a more flavorful experience compared to many super-dark blends out there.
Read the full review here.
3. Lavazza Gran Créma Espresso
Lavazza Gran Créma Espresso brings together the zest of South American beans, delicate fragrances from Asian varieties, and the robust punch of African highland coffees, creating an enticing medium roast with a rich body and a touch of smoky nostalgia.
Brewed as an espresso, this blend shines and unveils its true depth. The medium-dark roast strikes a perfect balance! As an espresso the gorgeous, velvety crema that crowns your cup is like the cherry on top, adding a creamy delight to each sip.
For those craving creaminess in their drinks, Lavazza Gran Créma is a dream base for cappuccinos and lattes, satisfying your frothy desires. But hold on – if you’re a purist who loves a straightforward, bold espresso shot, fear not, as this blend packs just the right amount of punch.
Versatility is the name of the game here. Whether you need an instant kick with an espresso shot, a frothy indulgence with a cappuccino, a creamy treat with a latte, or a comforting drip coffee, Lavazza Gran Créma delivers without a hint of disappointment.
Read the full review on Lavazza Gran Creama here.
2. Kirkland Signature House Blend Coffee: A Smooth and Balanced Delight
First things first – let’s talk about the secret behind this blend’s goodness. Brace yourself – it’s custom roasted by none other than Starbucks! Yes, you read that right. So, if you adore the rich, roasted flavor of Starbucks coffee, you’re in for a treat with this blend.
This blend isn’t about showing off; it’s all about chilling and enjoying the moment. It’s smooth, well-rounded, and has that perfect balance that’ll make you reach for another cup.
Now, Kirkland Signature House Blend is labeled as a medium roast, but hey, don’t be fooled – its flavor leans towards the darker side. This coffee is bold, dark, and oh-so-oily, with a delightful chocolatey-almond twist that’ll have you craving more.
And here’s some good news – these 100 percent Arabica beans are not only delicious but also Fair Trade Certified, making each sip feel even more satisfying, knowing it’s good for everyone involved in its creation.
Read the full review here.
1. Peet’s Coffee Major Dickason’s
Our choice for best coffee at Costco is Peet’s Major Dickason’s. You can’t go wrong with this blend. The star of this coffee is a robust scorched wood essence, stealing the show in both aroma and taste. Trailing behind this bold note are hints of chocolate and earthy sweetness. And if you pay close attention, you might just catch a delightful whiff of lemon and spice, like a hint of cardamom in the air.
The complexity of Major Dickason’s doesn’t stop at its flavor. It’s a blend of beans from various regions, adding depth and uniqueness to every sip. Talk about a coffee adventure that keeps you intrigued!
Now, here’s a little mystery for you – the exact origins of the beans in this blend are a well-kept secret. But fear not, my coffee explorers, it’s this blend of beans from multiple regions that gives Major Dickason’s its complex and rich flavor profile.
The roaster describes it as rich, smooth, spicy, and intricate – and trust me, it lives up to the hype. And here’s a bonus – this coffee is low in acidity, making it a fantastic choice for those who prefer a gentler brew without the sharp tang.
So, who is Peet’s Coffee Major Dickason’s for?
Peet’s Coffee Major Dickason’s is a crowd pleaser. If you want quality coffee that doesn’t break the bank and satisfies just about everyone then go with this.
If you crave an intense and roasty coffee experience with a touch of sweetness and spice to keep things interesting, this blend is tailor-made for you. And if you’re looking for a coffee that’s easy on the tummy, Major Dickason’s has your back.
Read the full review here.
